The 10 brands, and what to buy from each
1. Bare Hands
The best nontoxic option, period — because there's no polish at allThis is my honest #1 pick if you want zero exposure, not just less exposure. The Dry Gloss Manicure Kit skips polish entirely — a glass polisher buffs and binds the nail's keratin layers to a natural shine, paired with a plant-based cuticle oil, no UV lamp, no fumes, no chipping, no removal process at all. It's less a polish swap and more a full rethink of what a "manicure" even is.
Vegan, polish-free — nothing to be "free from" because there's no polish formula at all.
★ Star productThe Dry Gloss Manicure Kit ↗ — glass polisher + plant-based cuticle oil + cleaning cloth in a vegan leather case. Shine that lasts days to weeks with zero paint, zero solvents, zero lamp.
Check it out → 2. Manucurist
French, plant-based, and the gel system that actually removes gentlyManucurist's Green Flash line is made with up to 84% plant-based ingredients and is free of endocrine disruptors like toluene, DBP, and formaldehyde, plus HEMA and other methacrylate monomers most "clean" gel brands still use. The gel system cures under LED light for 10-14 days of wear, but removes in about a minute with their peel-off remover — no acetone soak, no filing down your natural nail.
Vegan and cruelty-free, made in France.
★ Star productActive Glow (Green Flash) + the Green Flash Gel System ↗ — Active Glow is a 2-in-1 color-and-treatment shade with raspberry extract, AHAs, and sweet almond oil actually formulated to restore fragile nails while you wear it. Pair it with the full Green Flash gel system (base, lamp, remover) for a salon-level at-home gel manicure.
Check it out → 3. Olive & June
Nontoxic and at Target — the most accessible pick on this listOlive & June markets as 7-free but has quietly become 15-free, cutting formaldehyde, formaldehyde resin, toluene, DBP, camphor, triphenyl phosphate, and more, while staying vegan and cruelty-free. What actually sets them apart is The Poppy — a patented handle that stabilizes your grip for a salon-quality at-home application — and the fact that you can pick this up at Target instead of waiting on a shipment.
Vegan and cruelty-free.
★ Star productThe Poppy Polish Set + the Gel System ↗ — The Poppy handle turns any bottle into an ergonomic, easier-to-control tool for streak-free application. Their gel system is HEMA-free and 15-free, with an LED lamp that cures a whole hand at once for up to 21 days of wear.
Check it out → 4. Lippmann
A cult-favorite AHA treatment I'm actually wearing right nowDeborah Lippmann's AHA Nail Sheer is formulated without the 25 most common harmful ingredients found in conventional nail polish, powered by gentle AHAs and botanical extracts that actually work on the nail while you wear it, not just sit on top of it. I've been using this one myself and it's held up genuinely well — sheer, natural-looking color that doubles as nail care instead of just decoration.
Formulated without 25 commonly flagged nail polish ingredients.
★ Star productAHA Nail Sheer ↗ — A sheer treatment-polish hybrid (available in Blush and Bare) that restores and rejuvenates the nail surface while giving a soft, healthy-looking finish. My personal pick on this whole list.
Check it out → 5. Côte
10-free, vegan, and one of the most talked-about clean polish brands right nowCôte was co-founded by Mary Lennon and Leah Yari and has become one of the go-to names in clean nail care — 10-free, made without formaldehyde, DBP, toluene, camphor, TPHP, xylene, parabens, silicone, sulfates, or PEGs. I haven't personally tried this one yet, but the ingredient standards and reputation put it solidly on this list.
Vegan and cruelty-free.
★ Star productNon-Toxic Nail Polish ↗ — Chip-resistant, high-performance color built on a clean, refined 10-free formula — a strong pick if you want color, not just treatment.
Check it out → 6. butter LONDON
8-free with a cult following, and the Patent Shine formula levels it up furtherbutter LONDON's core lacquers are 8-free — no formaldehyde, formaldehyde resin, DBP, toluene, camphor, ethyl tosylamide, xylene, or TPHP — with the Patent Shine 10X line pushing further to 10-free and vegan. Most formulas are actually free of 21 flagged "nasties" total, ahead of what the marketing number suggests.
Vegan (Patent Shine line) and cruelty-free brand-wide.
7. Londontown
The deepest ingredient exclusion list on this list — 21+ freeLondontown's Lakur polish is built on a proprietary Florium Complex — a botanical and vitamin blend meant to actually hydrate and strengthen nails while you wear color, not just coat them. The formula excludes phthalates, parabens, silicones, and gluten, landing at 21+ free, one of the longer exclusion lists of any mainstream nail brand.
Vegan and cruelty-free.
★ Star productLakur Nail Polish ↗ — 21+ free, vegan, streak-resistant color in 160+ shades, applied with a wide Pro-Contour brush designed to hug the cuticle line for cleaner edges.
Check it out → 8. OPI Nature Strong
A mainstream salon brand's first real nontoxic, plant-based lineOPI is about as mainstream as nail polish gets, which makes Nature Strong notable — their first fully vegan line, built from up to 75% plant and mineral-based ingredients, 9-free (formaldehyde, formaldehyde resin, toluene, xylene, DBP, camphor, parabens, ethyl tosylamide, and TPHP all excluded). Bottles use 20% post-consumer recycled plastic. It's proof that even the biggest names in the category can reformulate without giving up performance.
100% vegan and cruelty-free.
9. ella+mila
Made in the USA, and quietly upgraded from 7-free to 17-freeella+mila started as a 7-free brand and has since pushed to 17-free — now excluding acetone, BPA, gluten, parabens, and phthalates on top of the original list, while staying vegan, PETA certified, and made in the USA. It's a solid, accessible option if you want a long exclusion list without paying luxury nail polish prices.
Vegan, PETA certified cruelty-free.
★ Star productNail Lacquer, 17-Free ↗ — 17-free, vegan, made in the USA — one of the longest ingredient exclusion lists on this list at a genuinely accessible price point.
Check it out → 10. Zoya
The brand that pioneered clean nail polish in the first placeZoya was the original — the first brand to go 5-free, then the first Big 10 Free, and now formulates Big 12 Free (adding lead, styrene, and TPO to the standard exclusion list). Zoya's formula is also breathable and water-permeable, which actually matters for nail health during longer wear, and their glitter is mica-based instead of microplastic.
Vegan-friendly formula, longtime cruelty-free brand.
★ Star productZoya Nail Polish ↗ — Big 12 Free, breathable, vegan-friendly, in 400+ shades — the longest track record of any brand on this list when it comes to reformulating ahead of the industry.
Check it out → Frequently asked questions
What does "free-from" mean on nail polish (5-free, 10-free, etc.)?
It refers to how many commonly flagged ingredients a formula excludes — usually starting with the "toxic trio" (formaldehyde, toluene, DBP) and expanding to camphor, formaldehyde resin, xylene, TPHP, parabens, and more as brands push further. A higher number generally means a longer exclusion list, but it's not a regulated or standardized claim, so it's worth checking what's actually excluded rather than just the number.
Is gel manicure polish more toxic than regular polish?
Not inherently — the concern with gel is usually the UV lamp (a real but generally low, occasional-exposure risk) and HEMA, a methacrylate monomer linked to allergic reactions that's still common in many gel formulas. Brands like Manucurist and Olive & June specifically formulate HEMA-free, which is worth looking for if you're switching to a nontoxic gel system.
Is a polish-free manicure actually better than nontoxic polish?
It's the lowest-exposure option by definition, since there's no polish formula at all — just a buffing tool and cuticle oil, like the Bare Hands Dry Gloss Kit. It's not for everyone if you want actual color, but it's worth considering as a rotation option between polish manicures.
Do nontoxic nail polishes last as long as conventional ones?
Formulas have improved a lot — brands like Zoya, OPI Nature Strong, and Londontown are built specifically to compete with conventional performance, and gel systems from Manucurist and Olive & June claim 10-21 days of wear. The bigger tradeoff historically was color payoff and formula texture, and most of the brands on this list have closed that gap.
More clean beauty swaps
Skincare, makeup, and more — every product in Body & Beauty is vetted against my standards.
Shop Nails →This post contains affiliate links — if you buy through them I earn a small commission at no cost to you. Every pick meets my standards regardless.